Play-Offs
1. Jeff Thill
vs.
8. Joe Salazar
| Game 1 | Thill | 12 |
| Salazar | 1 | |
| Game 2 | Thill | 9 |
| Salazar | 4 | |
| Game 3 | Thill | 7 |
| Salazar | 6 | |
| Game 4 | Thill | 12 |
| Salazar | 4 |
Thill Wins Series 4 Games to 0.
2. Rich Thill
vs.
7. Steve Sallay
| Game 1 | Thill | 9 |
| Sallay | 4 | |
| Game 2 | Thill | 6 |
| Sallay | 1 | |
| Game 3 | Thill | 11 |
| Sallay | 2 | |
| Game 4 | Thill | 7 |
| Sallay | 0 |
Rich Thill Wins Series 4 games to 0.
3. Adam Thill
vs.
6. Jerry March
| Game 1 | Thill | 6 |
| March | 5 | |
| Game 2 | March | 8 |
| Thill | 7 | |
| Game 3 | March | 5 |
| Thill | 2 | |
| Game 4 | March | 6 |
| Thill | 5 | |
| Game 5 | Thill | 10 |
| March | 0 | |
| Game 6 | Thill | 6 |
| March | 3 | |
| Game 7 | Thill | 5 |
| March | 2 |
Adam Thill Wins Series 4 games to 3.
4. Jim Rzonca
vs.
5. Dan Lord
| Game 1 | Lord | 7 |
| Rzonca | 6 | |
| Game 2 | Rzonca | 11 |
| Lord | 7 | |
| Game 3 | Rzonca | 8 |
| Lord | 6 | |
| Game 4 | Rzonca | 10 |
| Lord | 7 | |
| Game 5 | Rzonca | 10 |
| Lord | 5 |
Jim Rzonca Wins Series 4 games to 1.
Semi-Finals
1. Jeff Thill
vs.
4. Jim Rzonca
| Game 1 | Thill | 9 |
| Rzonca | 8 | |
| Game 2 | Thill | 9 |
| Rzonca | 3 | |
| Game 3 | Thill | 5 |
| Rzonca | 4 | |
| Game 4 | Thill | 11 |
| Rzonca | 3 |
Jeff Thill Wins Series 4 Games to 0.
2. Rich Thill
vs.
3. Adam Thill
| Game 1 | Rich | 6 |
| Adam | 4 | |
| Game 2 | Adam | 6 |
| Rich | 5 | |
| Game 3 | Rich | 12 |
| Adam | 1 | |
| Game 4 | Rich | 16 |
| Adam | 3 | |
| Game 5 | Rich | 7 |
| Adam | 6 |
Rich Thill Wins Series 4 Games to 1.
2005 MHL Championship Series
# 1 Jeff Thill
vs
# 2 Rich Thill
The top dogs of the MHL hook up for the Championship series.
Things get a little heated when the championship is on the line.
The Garbage Man doesn't go down without a Fight!
| Game 1 | Jeff | 7 |
| Rich | 2 | |
| Game 2 | Rich | 6 |
| Jeff | 4 | |
| Game 3 | Rich | 10 |
| Jeff | 8 | |
| Game 4 | Jeff | 6 |
| Rich | 4 | |
| Game 5 | Jeff | 4 |
| Rich | 3 | |
| Game 6 | Rich | 7 |
| Jeff | 4 | |
| Game 7 | Jeff | 6 |
| Rich | 5 |
Jeff Thill Wins Series 4 Games to 3, and is the 2005 MHL Champion.
Jeff Thill being presented the with the Overall 1st place Trophy, Jeff Thill gets his name on the Big One.
Vezina Trophy, and 2005 Championship Trophy.
Adam Thill being presented Rookie of the Year.